| 9. Disorders of the
Oropharyngeal Phase of Deglutition |
page
113 |
A variety
of structural and functional disorders can disrupt the oropharyngeal phase
of deglutition and result in oropharyngeal or "transfer"-type
dysphagia (Table 4).
In the assessment of these patients it is important to exclude disorders
for which specific treatment is available.
TABLE 4.
Classification of disorders causing oropharyngeal dysphagia
Central nervous system disease
Cerebrovascular accident (brainstem, pseudobulbar palsy)
Wilson's disease
Multiple sclerosis
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis
Brainstem neoplasm
Tabes dorsalis
Peripheral nervous system disease
Bulbar poliomyelitis
Miscellaneous peripheral neuropathies
Head and neck neoplasms
Post-radical neck surgery
Muscle disease
Muscular dystrophy
Polymyositis and dermatomyositis
Metabolic myopathy (e.g., hypo- and hyperthyroidism)
Amyloidosis
Systemic lupus erythematosus
Myasthenia gravis
Local disorders
Oropharyngeal inflammation
Oropharyngeal neoplasms
Zenker's diverticulum
Idiopathic
Cricopharyngeal achalasia
Idiopathic oropharyngeal incoordination
|
The most important investigation is a carefully
performed video fluoroscopic study of the swallowing mechanism. In
addition to the usual barium studies, it is helpful to observe deglutition
when the patient swallows barium-soaked cookies or bread. Not only will
this examination identify and characterize disorders of oropharyngeal
coordination, it will also help exclude structural lesions. If an
inflammatory, neoplastic or other structural lesion is suspected, direct
or indirect laryngoscopy is indicated. At present, conventional manometric
studies of the pharynx and UES add little to what can be learned from
radiologic studies. This is partly because of limitations in recording
methods, but also because complex motor events occurring during
deglutition (e.g., closure of the nasopharynx, elevation and closure of
the larynx - see Section 3, "Physiology") are not amenable to
manometric study.
Ideally,
treatment of oropharyngeal motor disorders should be directed at the
underlying disease. Frequently this is not possible, and nonspecific
treatment must be instituted. In some cases reassurance and education are
all that is required. Many patients will be able to control their symptoms
simply by eating slowly and carefully in a relaxed atmosphere. In patients
in whom aspiration develops because of inadequate clearing of the
hypopharynx after the initial swallow, it is beneficial to have the
patient immediately follow a "bolus" swallow with a second,
"dry" swallow. Correcting denture problems and avoiding foods of
certain consistency may also help. Most speech pathologists have special
expertise as swallowing therapists and can be extremely helpful in the
management of these patients.
For
patients in whom these simple measures are not helpful and whose symptoms
are such that respiratory and nutritional complications are developing,
cricopharyngeal myotomy is often performed. This helps patients with true
cricopharyngeal achalasia or Zenker's diverticulum (Section 13).
Unfortunately, the response to myotomy is inconsistent in most other
patients with oropharyngeal dysphagia, because inadequate opening of the
UES is rarely due to dysfunction of the cricopharyngeal muscle alone. More
often there is associated weakness of the suprahyoid muscles, which
actually open the sphincter, and/or associated problems with pharyngeal
peristalsis. Cricopharyngeal myotomy does little to improve such altered
physiology. Once cricopharyngeal myotomy has been performed, the patient
has lost an important defense mechanism against the aspiration of refluxed
material. The patient should therefore be instructed to elevate the head
of his or her bed on blocks in order to minimize this risk. For this same
reason patients with gross GERD should not undergo cricopharyngeal myotomy
unless the reflux can be controlled.
When
all other measures fail and nutritional and respiratory complications
develop, percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy should be performed. If the
problem is so severe that the patient cannot handle salivary secretions,
it is sometimes necessary to also perform laryngeal exclusion and
tracheotomy. |