| 4. Methodology
in Clinical Research |
page
83 |
The
randomized, controlled trial is the benchmark for the evaluation of new
drug therapies. Random allocation is a powerful means of controlling for
the potential effects of confounders and serves to minimize bias
(systematic deviation from the truth) on the part of physicians and
patients. Concealing the treatment allocation from the patient and
investigator (blinding), which reduces the potential for bias, is also a
fundamental component of a rigorously designed clinical trial.
Considerable controversy has arisen regarding the use of placebo controls
in evaluating new drugs. Some authors have argued against their use on the
basis that patients are denied treatment of proven efficacy and thus may
experience some degree of morbidity by participation in a
placebo-controlled study. However, a placebo comparison allows an
evaluation of the new therapy against the alternative of no treatment, and
thus is scientifically valid and ethical when the standard therapy has
only modest efficacy or causes important adverse effects. In Phase III
trials it is vital that investigators choose as a primary measure of
response an outcome that is clinically meaningful. In the past there has
been an over-reliance on surrogate markers of efficacy such as
improvements in laboratory tests. In some instances these have been shown
not to correlate with clinically meaningful events. Investigators should
consider utilization of quality of life measures as measures of response
in addition to the more conventional outcomes of death, occurrence of
disease-related complications and clinical activity indices. Once an
appropriate outcome has been identified, the planning of a clinical trial
requires input from a biostatistician. Careful consideration is given to
the number of patients required, which is dependent upon the alpha (false
positive) and beta (false negative) error rates selected by the
investigator, the size of treatment effect that is considered to be
clinically meaningful and the estimated rate of occurrence of the outcome
of interest in the placebo (or standard therapy) group. If interim
analyses are planned, these must be defined prior to initiation of the
study, and appropriate statistical techniques employed to account for the
increase in the alpha error rate that results from the use of multiple
statistical testing procedures. |